Performance, Documentation, and Presence

A course journal on performance, documentation, and presence.

Morandi Siyuan Wu

CRIT 415

2025

I think the most inspiring takeaway from this week's readings starts in the last part of the article “Ontology of Performance” that I initially did not fully understand. As I connected ideas across other articles and my search about Roland Barthes, I realized how performance art and abstract concepts like love share ephemeral, unrepeatable, and memory-dependent qualities that require documentation and recollection.

Barthe's concept of disappearing performative writing resonates me because both sides understand the "impossible". Love attempts to comprehend absence while acknowledging the impossibility of fully possessing or understanding the other at the same time. Here, presence and absence create profound connections because the true bonds among human are built on mutual recognition of what cannot be retained. I thought about Barthes' concept of "recognizing the same impossible," for a long while and my understanding is that people are trying to feel each other's presence in absence. This connection is not based on complete possession of the other person, but on a common understanding of absence. For example, a friend of who has been separated for many years will unconsciously think of her when seeing a lake in the rain that we once enjoyed together, and even my daily habits are influenced by her. Memories cannot perfectly reproduce the scene and state of mind at that time, and even my own feelings cannot be reproduced. Therefore, absence does not only refer to the departure of a friend, but also to those elements that have already been “completed”/ “done”. It is the acceptance of these unrepeatable elements, same in performance art” that helps us to write and document better. In this way, we are not just recreating/reproducing/reperforming the “done” part but also revealing and documenting the “unseen” part which are inevitably affected by the “done” part.

For me, this is a very romantic comparison which emphasizes the aspects of human interaction, the construction and extension or maintenance of relationship in performance art. It bring back the discussion to “human” and all objects picked by humans (this could be a more general definition, such as something picked, affected by humans). Therefore, in performance art, Interaction goes beyond individuals to encompass groups, “ecosystems”, and constructed environments. Initially, I prioritized "time" as the key element of performance art, but I now believe human interaction holds greater significance. Subjective experiences such as forgetting, recalling, and rewriting propel the passage of time. While time influences human experience, humans are the primary agents driving change and meaning.

Performance art emphasizes the "now" which highlights its ephemeral nature. Each repetition could make the performance inherently different but acting as a spur to memory and encouraging memory to become present action. Performance art fosters an interactive exchange between the art object and the viewer. For instance, in Sophie Calle's work, it illustrates how forgetting becomes the fundamental energy of descriptive recovery—a process where meaning emerges through a combination of personal action and the disappearance of the object. This further supports the idea that documentation is not intended for preservation but instead brings attention to the value of “disappearance”. Same in Dislocation, making visible what cannot be seen is just a way to emphasize the choice of whom to perform for or invite who to participate. Therefore, “absence” becomes a key element in performance art for it can encourage people to reflect on what is lost. Performance implicates the real through the presence of living bodies while at the same time spending but saving nothing. And this is the valuable part of performance art in the modern capitalist context that it reevaluates emptiness and challenges the reproductive representation that drives the circulation of capital. At this stage, writing, speaking and documentation serve as ways to bring performance into broader dialogue: explain non-widely accessible knowledge, certain group shared ideas, cultural expressions to the public thereby emphasizing the voices of certain cultures or groups of people.

However, I need to clarify my idea about the differences between live performance and documented performance art forms because this directly relates to the debate of viewing/participating in live performances versus watching digital recordings. Live performance involves real-time interactions among the audience, performers, and even technical staff like the cameraman, while also engaging with the uncertainty of the environment, crowd reactions, spatial arrangements, and energy exchanges. Elements like body movement, eye contact, and perspective arrangement are experiences that cannot be replicated digitally. Especially in a group participation performance, I believe each person plays a unique role based on their position, identity, the people around them and so on. On the other hand, digital recording lacks the immediacy and interactive energy of live performance, such as uncertainty and the unknown future. However, documentation serves to make knowledge, cultural voices, and marginalized perspectives more accessible to the public. I just feel it is essential to clarify the differences between the two formats and recognizing their complementary roles rather than positioning one as superior to the other. I believe that from the perspective of spreading public art ideas, documentation is necessary and crucial, while in terms of experiencing the “now,” live performance includes more factors. From my perspective, documentation is always a recreation, even when created by artists themselves, with changes in moment, expectation, and perception.

ALL WRITING
↗