Collective Performance and Social Space
A course journal on collective performance and social space.
This week's post reminds me of my memories of listening to professor Suzanne Lacy talk about the collective participation/performance art pieces she made in her class last year, and I feel as though I understand the meaning of her work better now than I did then. She mentioned several pieces including The Roof is on Fire, The Circle and the Square, and Between the Door and the Street, all of which I think are particularly good examples of reenactment and thinking about the relationship between space, time, and the body. I will mainly analyze the work Between the Door and the Street.
Dread Scott's Slave Rebellion Reenactment made me feel similarly. He has hundreds of African Americans marching through New Orleans in 1811 slave garb in a re-enactment of the ultimately failed slave revolt of the past. But this time, they “made it” into the heart of the city, waving flags like victors. This is not the “real” history, but a fictionalized ending. But it is this fictionalization that creates an emotional charge; Dread Scott is not trying to revise history, but to create a physical experience in which people can feel victorious. As Foster says, the body of protest is not a tool, but an expression. Every body that marched, paused, turned, and shouted in the march was a rewritten language of history, an embrace of “the end we never had”.
As I read Schneider, I also took particular note of her discussion of the "ethics of viewing. Her statement that video is both reenactment and control made me think long and hard about it, and I think about it in relation to the discussion of documentation & reenactment from a few weeks ago. For example, when we look at the videos and photos of Slave of Rebellion, the images of the uniforms and cheering crowds are actually edited and selected. We are only looking at a certain angle of history, a certain photographer's choice. Did the people who actually participated in this reenactment see it differently? Did those who sweated under the hot sun and walked at the front of the line feel differently from those who stood by the side of the road and watched? I began to realize that while video amplifies the communicative power of performance, it also changes the structure of its viewing - it recompresses a space that should be multi-pointed into a linear, directed “viewer's point of view”. And reenactment itself breaks this control of viewing. Dread Scott's performances, for example, are not staged, and there are no clear boundaries of “you're watching me”. Crowds can join in, photography can flow freely, and everyone seems to be a participant. It creates more alternative viewing paths, making viewing more dispersed, more flexible, and more uncertain. This ambiguity is rather more real - it makes us constantly aware that we are looking and being guided at the same time, and in this uncertainty, the viewing itself becomes action. These readings also made me rethink what “remembrance” really is. I used to think of memorialization as a kind of “preservation” - like a statue, an inscription, an archive - a way of fixing memories for people to see. But Schneider and Anagnost showed me a completely different kind of memorialization: Dread Scott's performance was a kind of “processual memorialization”. It doesn't leave anything material behind, but it allows hundreds of bodies to come together to tell a story that has been repressed, to make a journey out of that unfinished part of history. This kind of memorialization does not try to “preserve” anything, but tries to “make” something happen. It is more like a resonance of emotions, an activation of space. I even think that having women sit on a porch and talk, as in Lacy's work, is also a form of memorialization - a way of remembering the women who silently resisted in their homes, churches, kitchens, and battlefields, and whose voices have not been written down in history books.
And finally, I'd like to say a little something about space in particular. In the past, I used to think of space as a “site” - where the work is done, whether it's in a museum, on the street, or in a neighborhood. But now I am slowly beginning to feel that space itself is also involved in the performance. It is not an empty container, but a breathing presence. In Slave Rebellion, the performer travels through what was once a slave plantation and is now a petrochemical factory; those locations are not the backdrop, but the narrator. In Lacy's work, the porch is not a set, but a meeting point of social classes, cultural backgrounds, and neighborhoods. I began to think that space is actually an “organism” - it responds to people, it can be activated, and it can be suppressed. It can respond to people, it can be activated, and it can be suppressed. Between it and the human body, it can exchange emotions, energy, and even the weight of history.