Repetition and Interaction
A course journal on repetition and interaction.
The key words I distilled after reading this week's readings were repetition and interaction. Repetition, recreation, re-perform, and production are not static. It is a dynamic repetition, depending on the time (in the grand scheme, the aesthetic and ideological differences between eras), place, and audience chosen for the performance. And this is an important point in post-WWII art, because it challenges the linear perspective of history. It also helped me to better understand the dynamic significance of performances and artworks. Because they are often pioneering, the same work can be interpreted completely differently in different times, and a linear historical perspective can easily bury the meaning of the different cultures and the voices of the groups behind them. In my cousin's middle school, a history chart was popular, a long line drawn from left to right, with each node being an event and the name of the person as a pronoun. When I asked him who he thinks are great historical figures, it was the ones listed on the history table that came to his mind first. The article also mentioned this idea: many events, works and styles will be used in this way to help refine a representation as a way to increase the discourse power which makes it easy to emphasize and summarize. But such “reproduction” is a kind of repetition that ignores the voices of many individuals and marginalized groups. Who made the categorization, who named it, who had the right to make the choice? The emphasis on “originator” in art history is also inextricably linked to this linear narrative and repetition, and Pollock is often referred to as the “father of action painting,” a title that not only simplifies the complexity of art history but also reinforces the link between art and individual heroism. This title not only simplifies the complexity of the form of his art style, but also reinforces the association between art and individual heroism. However, as discussed in the article, this singular narrative tends to overlook Pollock's assimilation of Native American sand painting and blues music, as well as his interactions with the artists of his time. Like nodes in a linear graph of history compressed for clarity, they tend to deny the presence and contributions of many individuals. Art history needs to revisit this narrative model to include more collectivity and cross-cultural dialog in its discussions.
Much of the post-World War II art and performance has challenged just such a centralized discourse. It has also allowed for works, actions, arts to have the opportunity to present very different metaphors in different social contexts. I also understand the importance of video and photography in the reproduction of art and performance better: they not only document the original work, but also extend the life of the art beyond the creative process itself, allowing it to be presented to different groups, in different times and ideologies.
Repetition is also a form of education that can be more widely realized by society, extending to reflections on life. For example, the realization that a certain style or behavior may be appreciated not because of the visual impact of the work itself, but because of the choices of the times and tastes under this “weapon of taste”. For actions after WW-II traditional European painting may have represented “old ideas,” while innovative forms such as abstraction may have been interpreted as a more modern, up-to-date form of art that dared to make changes in high taste. This phenomenon reflects the mechanism by which societies and cultures construct ideologies and social status through art. But at the same time, I wonder if this obsession with the “new” is also a neglect of diversity. And who dominates the right to choose, and to what extent do the media and authoritative discourse play a role in this?
Pollock's work also provides me with another understanding of repetition and interaction. The process of creating his “drip paintings” is a “ritualized” act, not just a visual work, but a performance art in a broader sense. Viewing his huge paintings is not just about perceiving the picture itself, but about entering into a visual experience that is wrapped up in the viewer's subjective feelings and interaction with reality. From personal creative experience, I created a large painting with a foot of the same size as a person trapped in a bed at the end of last semester. Before that I hadn't thought that this could be understood as a form of performance. But it does allow the viewer to immerse themselves and imagine that that equally proportioned limb belongs to them. I think this continuity is equally important in my painting practice. Repetition can extends art from the frame and canvas to a wider reality, making it a continuous “behavior” and “experience”.