Deep Listening and Attunement

A course journal on deep listening and attunement.

Morandi Siyuan Wu

CRIT 415

2025

Deep listening is a more detailed and experiential interaction with the environment that incorporates multi-sensory experiences. I feel that deep listening requires more than just attentive listening, but also spiritual involvement. The core part is to abandon all preconceived ideas when listening, give back senses to the environment, and to accept all the noise, silence, changes, and static states. Many of the ideas and examples mentioned in Julia Steinmetz's article continue to evoke my personal experiences of sound and the “listening” experience. Among them, the three concepts: environment mother, tuning to attunement and multi-demensional listening resonate deeply with me. I marvel at the fact that behind those unconscious “efforts to listen” there is actually so much to think about the connection between the environment and society.

Oliveros's concept of multi-demensional listening mentions that the environment itself is also a musical instrument. So I think that deep listening is a kind of listening with the whole body, giving the audience time, space and some hint to pay attention to all the information in the space they are in. It is like what Freud advocated: in psychological counseling attention should be paid to all sounds, even the silence and sounds abstracted into body movements. What makes up the whole of sound is not just a single individual making a sound, but every element in the ensemble of the entire environment. I was surprised to find that this feeling resonates deeply with my experience in recording the sound for videos.

When recording interviews for a documentary project, even if everyone is quiet, I often feel that the sound in my headphones is unclear and full of noise. I think this is what Oliveros calls untrained “hearing”, which passively accepts the sounds in the environment. At this time, in order to better record and receive sound, I will enter a process of “deep listening” to feel and observe all the sound-making objects in my environment. The friction of clothing, the car honking outside the window, the draft paper blowing in the wind, and the sound of the air conditioner and air purifier that have always been in the background (I have always ignored but that have always been there during repeated recording attempts). The process of eliminating each environmental sound and testing the recording in the headphones is amazing. It feels like a kind of reverse listening, as if I am actively shaping a new listening space. This process has given me a new understanding of “silence” itself. In “slow listening” (because for me this is a process, I was not able to immediately recognize the elements that make up the “spatial orchestral music” in the background) I heard more and more elements that make up the sound, and then eliminated them one by one. I went from a state of “silence” that had not entered into deep listening to listening to a silence that had eliminated many sounds. But even at this time, it was not complete silence in the full sense of the word. I was still able to hear many sound elements in this moment of silence that I could not hear in the previously defined silence, such as shallow breathing, heartbeat and so on. This precisely reflects the theme of “quiet” explored in Oliveros idea and 4'33”, even if everyone is ‘quiet’, there are still countless sounds in the background. ‘Silence’ is not absolute silence, but a certain controllable sound structure. Every time I eliminate noise, I am redefining the experience and response to the environment as an individual, which is a creative process.

The article also mentions the concept of “environment mother”. It is about the fact that our ears are trained to a singular attunement of human speech in the environment in which we grow from the womb to the real world. We respond to specific sounds and unconsciously believe that we “only hear” a certain sound (this sound can be a specific tone, the appeal of a certain group..). What we hear often depends not on what the ambient sound contains, but on long-term social conditioning and the environment in which we grow up, which trains us to pay attention to what we hear, what we care about, and “how to quickly filter out the necessary information from the clutter”. From a macro perspective, this refers to hearing which side's voice is heard in a society full of debate, and being aware of the existence of various groups and their demands. In traditional concepts, it seems that whoever has the louder voice has the right to speak. Even today, there is often talk of “driving traffic” (attract user traffic and find potential users)

on the internet. What is promoted more, and what is heard and seen more often, will often become “good” and “right”; which voices are considered “important” and which are ignored are often also determined by the social power structure. Because the dominant narrative can determine which “voices” should exist and which “noises” should be eliminated, they can use their power to amplify the voices they want to be heard and make the voices they don't want to be heard infinitely smaller and closer to silence. For example, the “voices” of women can be understood as their contributions, achievements, demands, and dilemmas throughout history, but in the context of patriarchy, the research results involving women have been repeatedly named after men, burying women's dilemmas and beautifying them as “virtues” that trap women through various means. The significance of deep listening lies in listening with the whole body to perceive different “layers of sound” and discover the protests and efforts made by different groups of people that have been buried under the mainstream voice.

Combining with the previous thinking about silence, I think we should actively choose how to construct “silence”, rather than accepting the “silence” defined by the social power structure. There are also many layers of sound in “silence”, but they are all like the state of no sound that I mistakenly thought when I first tried to record because I did not consciously listen.

I once talked about this childhood story with friends in conversation: when we were in primary school and junior high school, we were very good at listening to footsteps, and could even tell who was walking towards the room door by the different footsteps. Back then, parents were very strict on our homework and bedtime, we needed to follow parents’ rules without doing anything else. But we all couldn't help wanting to play, secretly reading storybooks, playing with mobile phones, drawing, chatting online... These things can't be done in front of the parents, and can only be done secretly when they are not in the room watching us. Once they are found walking towards the study room, we have to quickly hide the things we are playing with and pretend to do our homework. I am more afraid of my father, so I pay more attention to his footsteps. Compared to my mother's footsteps, his footsteps are steadier and heavier, and the slippers he walks in don't drag on the ground. In this environment, I slowly trained myself to identify the owner, distance and even the mood of the footsteps by the details I heard. Later I could even easily tell from the sound of footsteps whether the couple upstairs were welcoming their host family's daughter back, arguing or rushing around packing. The sound of footsteps seemed to become an important part of my alone time in front of the desk during that period. Later, when I was in high school, my parents stopped supervising me so closely and let me manage my time myself. I found that my ability to do this gradually deteriorated, and sometimes I didn't even notice my mother walk to the door. I would joke with friends that growing up and becoming an adult would make me lose a lot of the abilities of childhood.

But after reading this article today, I no longer feel that this was just a mischievous game in my past, but rather realize how the environment has shaped me to consciously listen to what I hear. This confirms what Steinmetz mentioned in the article: listening is not a purely sensory activity, but a process of psychological, social and cultural interaction. For me as a child, listening was to some extent a survival strategy. My parents set strict rules for me to follow, and listening and recognizing their footsteps became an important tool for me to circumvent power control. What I “hear” does not just depend on my physical “hearing” but also on my conscious “choice”: my sensitivity to footsteps as a child was enhanced by the fact that I “actively” listened and tried to interpret them. I realize that listening is not a decision that I make directly as an individual, but a response to social behavior that has been trained through long-term close interaction in a social environment. What I hear, what I choose to hear, and what I focus on listening to have shaped my experiences and have been further changed by my growth. To listen, to hear, and to listen attentively is a long-term social behavior that is often intertwined with the environment.

Like another concept mentioned in the article: from Tuning to Attunement. Oliveros transforms tuning into attunement as part of meditation, that is, transforming the sound heard as an individual into a continuous interaction with the environment, and adjusting in the interaction to achieve a state of harmony between the sounds. This reminds me of my experience at metabolic studio. We once organized a community singing event. The content to be sung was very simple, just one sentence, written in a local language: “May the water find the roots”. Under the guidance of a conductor, we repeated the lyrics in different tones. Each syllable was long, so if we wanted to cooperate well on the long sounds, we needed to listen to each other's voices and lean towards the same sound position. At the same time, the space where we sang was a very high and empty warehouse-like space, and the sound felt like it was bouncing back and forth throughout the space. At first, we were all unfamiliar with each other, and no one dared to sing out loud. But slowly, one voice became louder, and the other voices slowly caught up to it, reaching a louder overall sound. In the process of repeating this cycle, at first I could clearly hear my own singing, but as I slowly caught up to the overall singing, I seemed to feel my own voice become blurred, because everyone's voices formed a kind of wonderful resonance in the space, as if they had reached a certain kind of synchronized frequency. Even when the instructor asked us to walk around the space at will, I could no longer hear individual voices as easily as I had at the beginning, but instead was constantly immersed in the sound space composed of the overall sound.

I feel that this is the part of the experience that is particularly in line with the transition from tuning to attunement. Initially, everyone's voice was independent. I also tried to adjust my own voice at the individual level to be more in tune with others in the environment. As we walked around, we kept listening to the voices of others, no longer just humming as individuals, but “tuning” each other's voices and trying to enter into resonance. Listening is no longer passive, but a dynamic social process in which each individual actively seeks to integrate into the whole. As empathy grows, the sounds in the space seem to become one, a flow containing countless individual sounds. This shared “flow” ultimately influences each other through the link of “listening,” which continues to take place.

ALL WRITING
↗