The Emotional Difficulty of Art
A course journal on the emotional difficulty of art.
For this week's reading I found Doyle's articles very interesting, so I will mainly focus on her two articles to write this week's journal.
Mitchell's Death is one of the works that impressed me the most. As discussed in class, it reminds me of Buddhist chanting, constantly recalling a large number of details in a very stable rhythm through a uniform intonation and extremely restrained facial expressions. The internal narrative interspersed in the recitation, such as “am I strong enough,” is very touching. The needles on the artist's face seem to be the physical manifestation of these painful inner feelings, which contrasts strongly with the extremely restrained language and physical expression of emotion. The whole video gives me the feeling of creating a ritual form, just like in a Buddhist temple, where the echo, silence, and contrast between the height of the Buddha and the surroundings are used to create a solemn and respectful environment. The tension between language and emotion in the work makes me feel that her pain is a stable existence rather than a temporary outburst. It is an interactive environment that is constantly being constructed, even if the audience is just facing the screen as a listener and viewer. And the overall composition of the video is centered in black and white, gradually appearing and gradually disappearing. At first, I found it hard to bear the long, monotonous narration, but it gradually grew on me as it went on. I began to recall the way people in real life who are in extreme distress really do speak rapidly in a near-loss-of-voice manner when they cry out their pain, as if they can make the pain last a little less if they say it all in one go. And people in extreme distress really do at some point appear to be in a state of extreme calm which I understand as an emotional escape that isolates the pain from reality.
Combining the ideas in Doyle's article, Mitchell's Death is difficult to emotionally accept. Unlike tragic novels and movies, these aesthetically processed narratives, the real painful monologues are unbearable, with a direct impact and awakening of emotional experience. As an audience member, we are forced to confront this emotional experience of pain, to experience its realism. This is especially true in the case of live performing arts, where we cannot fast-forward through the story like a fictional novel or movie. Instead, we must unplug our emotional defenses and experience the emotion fully from beginning to end.
In Dolye's article, the difficulty of art is elevated to the emotional level, which is different from the traditional interpretation of art criticism, which is to “understand” abstract and difficult works. The perspective in this article made me realize that emotional and psychological difficulty or discomfort is also a kind of difficulty. For example, the article mentions works like Held that directly confront the audience with their own vulnerability or discomfort. This also made me think about “aesthetics” in art. In contemporary art, we no longer seem to look at beautiful, comfortable things, but more at works that have a sensory impact and are related to various community and social issues. Watching and feeling art is no longer just pure enjoyment, but requires the audience to face some frightening and difficult emotional experiences as both a viewer and a participant. Although this doesn't sound beautiful, it also happens to include what I think is the most touching part: the emotional flow/interaction between the artwork and the audience. When we have to face some emotional fluctuations and find that not everyone has the same emotional experience, it forces us to realize that those emotions we thought were personal are actually socially shaped, reflecting our upbringing, background, class, the power system we are in, and the privileges we enjoy. This fluidity achieves an effect of inclusion and connection. We are forced to share emotional experiences that we mistakenly believe to be individualized, and to compare and reflect on the feelings of others. In this way, we can feel how individual experiences exist in the external world around us, and how they interact and connect with people in the same space and time.
This also answers my previous questions about many “controversial” works, such as “why do these extreme behaviors exist?” and “where are the boundaries of art?” and so on. Perhaps the real controversy is not the work itself, but how the social contradictions pointed out by the work are perceived. When I focus on why this work exists and why it is called art, I just ignore the reason why it makes me feel doubtful and uncomfortable. But mainstream culture or most of the social media I come into contact with present more “easy” controversies than these kinds of thoughts. This reminds me of the performance art work “21 Days of a Celebrity” by the artist Zou Yaki (I'm not sure if this is the exact name of the work, as I couldn't find the exact name on the internet. I saw this work from a lot of media reports, and there are various comments on her actions online, but the interesting thing is that no one even labeled it as a serious work of art by its title). The background of this project is that the artist Zou Yaki pretended to be a celebrity in and lived for 21 days without spending money by entering “high-level” places and using “extra resources” in society. To some extent, this work challenges the fixity of “identity” in Chinese society, showing that the elite class is not absolutely closed, but relies on certain symbolic social behaviors. And at the same time, it challenges the narrative of “authenticity of identity”, as this experiment proves that identity can be constructed. This work has caused a great deal of controversy on social media. As Doyle's article says, it is not because the work itself is “too much”, but because it challenges a reality that the audience does not want to face. Many people's focus is on “is this deception?” and “is this consuming celebrity culture?” rather than whether it reveals a certain phenomenon in society. People focus on debating the moral issues in the process but ignore the social structure issues that the work wants to convey. This, in my opinion, is what the article means by “difficulty”. The first thing people think is: “So the elite system we believe in can be imitated?” This difficulty is not because the work itself is difficult to understand, but because the emotional impact of the challenge to class and identity is too much for people to bear.