Performativity and the Social Subject

A course journal on performativity and the social subject.

Morandi Siyuan Wu

CRIT 415

2025

In reading this week's articles, Butler's Performative Acts and Gender Constitution and Nyong's Between the Body and the Flesh, I felt a lot of counterintuitive ideas, especially ones such as “the subject is not the embodiment of the individual's will”. I was initially puzzled by these ideas, but after thinking about them more carefully, they made sense. Especially after connecting them to Foucault's idea I have studied before, I have a deeper understanding of the fluidity of identity and how society as a system of rights shapes the perception of the subject that we think comes from the individual himself.

In Butler's article one point is made that identities are not innate, but are defined and created through social expectations and countless repetitive practices. This is a counter-intuitive point to me because the perception of one's own identity is not formed by the individual, but rather by the “self” that is formed by obeying social norms and engaging in “stylized repetition”. Who we think we are is not because we really know who we are, but because we are constantly “performing” who we are perceived to be.

What I find interesting here is that as individuals we all have subjective ways of saying “who I am” or “who I want to be”. These voices that seem to come from within us as individuals are, according to Butler's theory, not individual, but rather shaped by a set of social norms such as language, behavior and so on. This reminds me of some of the examples I've seen on red book (a Chinese social media app), especially in relation to women. They are always limited by the label “female” when they want to be labeled as a competent professional, questioned or admired for being a woman who has achieved such a feat; and even became popular because of the contrast of being a woman.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ILQsYsnFMSQ This video features a housewife who is famous for her rapping ability. It's easy to see that she has a great talent for rapping and singing, but every one of her videos deliberately emphasizes her status as a “housewife” in the title and dress code. Her popularity is not only because of her talent, but also because of the contrast between her identity as a “mom” and “rapper”. While this “contrast” becomes attractive, it also illustrates that identity is fluid and can be reconstructed, and that women gain new subjectivity in this process of “constantly becoming”. But at the same time, I find it ironic that women need to gain attention by performing what society has labeled them as in order to be taken seriously, so that the audience can discover what she wants to be as a “subject” which is outside of the “female”, “mother”. I think this reflects the example of the Two Undiscovered Amerindians mentioned in Between the Body and the Flesh: the viewers think they are watching the Amerindians 'other', but in fact they are watching their own perception of the so-called 'other'.

So what is the tension between a person's “subjectivity” (who they want to be) and society's “labeling” of them? When a girl subjectively expresses the idea that “I want to be pretty and slim,” although it seems to be her subjective wish, the choice of “slim and pretty” is itself formed in a society and culture that promotes that visual culture. The so-called “free” choice of what one wants to be as a subject is actually a choice made within the framework set by society. In other words, our subjectivity is not about choosing “who I am” in a space of infinite freedom, but rather about picking an “okay” option from a menu that society has already written for us. “I want to be a successful artist”, ‘I want people to see me as a free and interesting person’. While these may sound like freely expressed desires of my heart, they are in fact partly internalized definitions of what social values have given me as an image of excellence and success. The choices I have made have been one of the options offered to me in social discipline, not a 100% free option. This is also true of gender, personality, and identity. So what is called subjectivity is really a decision within the range of options given rather than a completely free choice. These “ideas” already exist within a particular social structure, media culture so that they can “appear” in my mind.

This reminds me again of Michel Foucault's power theory. Society does not force us to do anything or make choices, but it can subconsciously make us “volunteer” to become the subject it wants us to be. Subjectivity then becomes a tool rather than true freedom. Society, through education, norms, laws, media and so on, creates the idea of us as subjects and makes us subscribe to this value system and internalize it so that we are willing to spontaneously self-manage and even punish ourselves. So I think the point of this article is not just about identity and gender, but on a larger scale, it reflects how society allows individuals to internalize social rules and norms through the production of “subjectivity” and at the same time perceive this as a form of freedom that leads to stability.

So when we talk about identity, choice, and expression, we can't just say, “I am free,” but we have to ask: where does my ‘freedom’ come from? Is it because society tells me “this is freedom”? From the perspective of contemporary social media and avatars, isn't “expressing oneself” on social media also a repetition of performing and practicing mainstream values? Is the labeling of “self-presentation” a new form of “governance”?

Nyong'o emphasizes in Between the Body and the Flesh about black identity and body also helped me better understand how race and bodily experience affect our subjectivity. For black people, the body carries a symbol of the suffering they have experienced in the past. And this symbol is collectivized, so when understanding subjectivity it is not only about the individual, but also about the oppression and unequal social structure of the collective that shares the symbol of the body. Simply saying “who I am” is not a good way to fight against oppression, but rather, by repeating “to be” and breaking through the social definition of the body symbol, (such as the example in article: I am not a man) a new kind of subjectivity can be created. This kind of performance often carries with extreme discomfort so that audience have to confront the discrimination in the social system. By creating discomfort, it provokes discomfort, which in turn provokes reflection.

Nyongo also mentions the term “radical availability” in his article, which means that a black artist's performance may be seen as “presenting the black experience” rather than expressing their own artistic language. This links back to the exploitation of identity subjectivity mentioned earlier. As mentioned above, women's identities are always sexualized or presented in stereotypical qualities, resulting in a reduced or ignored degree of freedom of subjectivity available to the individual. Therefore, expressing subjectivity is not a free choice, and very often our bodies and identities are. In fact, in a state of 'radical availability'- our body are always expected by society to take on a certain meaning, to represent. Even when we want to express ourselves, we are inevitably labeled. Identity becomes a resource to be 'called' and 'consumed', rather than something that truly belongs to us.

All of this has led me to reconceptualize the “subject”. As Butler says in the article, identity is “not a stable identity, but an identity tenuously constituted in time”. That means that subjectivity is not an “essence” that we have always possessed, but a process that is constantly being shaped, challenged, and redefined within social norms. I am not a fixed “I” but a person who lives in a constantly shifting position in society - student, woman, Asian, social media user ...... These identities all have socially assigned meanings. I switch back and forth between these identities and my subjectivity is fluid. It flows with the social rules and regulations, but it also flows with my struggles as an individual within the limitations. This is the process by which we “become ourselves”. Subjectivity is not the same as free expression, but is deeply shaped by society; but understanding this does not mean giving up the “self”, but rather re-examining the question of “who am I”. For example: I can make more conscious choices about how we present ourselves.

ALL WRITING
↗