Hotel 22 — Written Response
A close reading of duration, sound, displacement, and uneasy refuge in documentary film.
In Hotel 22, the first thing I noticed is that Elizabeth thrives on long, continuous shots within the bus, capturing its interior, scenes outside the window, people fell asleep and so on. When she filmed the bus interior, she chose to capture from the dim, shadowed front to the faintly lit rear. It subtly swayed with the vehicle’s movement, with a noisy sound accompanying the bus moving. The scene led me to think about the cradle which is a delicate and ironic metaphor here. Because the “cradle” usually means a safe and comfortable space, however, what we see through the camera is a fleeting night’s refuge accompanied by road noise and jolting bumps.
I also have a question about how she maintains such diverse, clear shots without disrupting the natural atmosphere or drawing the subjects’ attention? The passengers seem unaware of the camera, moving as if in a world of their own fatigue. But this is also the valuable part of this film, the perspective seems so close to reality, creating an authentic, almost voyeuristic experience for audience.
Moreover, the auditory design in this film is immersive too, which enhances the feeling of intimacy. Breathing sound blended with the monotone broadcast of the bus announcements forms a somber, ambient rhythm. Elizabeth focused on one passenger's breathing for a long while and then moved the camera to the outside scene and time title, but the breathing sound was kept in the background. And after the long stretches of this ambient noise, she successfully builds into moments of tension. And this calm was really disrupted by arguments that happened over time. I think this is a good control of rhythm for the whole film, and a nice depiction and choice of the events to create a rising emotion.
At the end of the film, when the sun rises, she captures contrasts between night and day, using the shift in passengers and seating arrangements to underscore social displacement. All the film shot of the thick layers of clothing, blurred window views, and shifting perspectives contribute to a strong sensory experience for me and successfully tell both the harshness of survival and the fleeting moments of uneasy peace in this shared space.