Meaning, Reading, and Seeing

A response on signification, interpretation, and the social conditions of reading art.

Morandi Siyuan Wu

ART 280

2024

Meaning is not absolute; meaning can change based on many elements such as time, personal experience, and vehicles of meaning mentioned in the text, including color, title, composition, medium, gesture, material, and so on. Meaning – Signification – Idea carried by the intention explained through the example of a door in the text helps me to come to realize that all carriers with "social nature" cannot be discussed without their social relevance, including art, language, and other forms. The social nature of these carriers implies that their interpretation relates to the relationship between subject and object, time, environment, method, form, and other factors. Meaning, in this context, is a complex collection that brings together all socially connected elements focused on either the object of interpretation or the subject experiencing it.

Next, I want to talk about Read & See. What we see is not necessarily what we read. There is an interactive connection between reading and seeing, which again emphasizes the social nature involved in interpreting art. The clue to understanding how to transfer what we see into what we read is through employing all the elements we know and experience as individuals, including our knowledge of society and history.

When we think about art as the language of socially-inclined visual language, we see that art remains a form of language—specifically, a visual or broader sensory language. As with any language, it contains both denotation and connotation because language itself is a product of social activity. The language created by an artist carries their personal expression and intention. From the artist’s perspective, the interpretation of their work is inherently personal. Meanwhile, as viewers, our interpretation stems from an individual standpoint, where we combine our own experiences to try and decode the artist's intention. In this process, we are not only interpreting the artwork itself but also considering its environment, the relationship between the artist and the work, and all the interactive elements within the space.

However, I have a question: Can subject matter or connotation be considered a type of meaning, or are they merely carriers? Do they only become meaningful once socially significant human understanding is introduced during interpretation?

“Meaning generated out of formal choices also comes up against our own guesses regarding the artist’s intentions.” This is one of the key takeaways for me from the reading. It emphasizes the importance of noticing unconventional, prescriptive aspects of an artwork, as these contrasts often hide the artist’s intention that can be shared with the viewer. For instance, in cases of common knowledge, like how God is typically understood as a grand figure, the meaning becomes compelling when the expression in the artwork contrasts with or challenges this conventional view, giving rise to a new layer of meaning.

Now, I want to shift to Message and Form. The interpretation of message and form often needs to be considered separately, but I believe that how form is used to convey a message is a crucial aspect of critique, one that particularly infuses the work with meaning. The text discusses various vehicles of meaning, such as color, medium, and composition, all of which deserve consideration when critiquing a work of art. This reminds me of a project from my freshman ART105 class, where we were asked to create a piece using 100 repeated objects. Despite the unified form, the different objects and compositions produced vastly different meanings. I recall one project where 100 busts were arranged to look as if they were drifting with ocean waves, while another project featured 100 pencils densely packed in a box. The former reflected on a social event from a collective standpoint, while the latter interpreted pressure and anxiety in a more personal way.

I particularly liked the statement, “art is at its best when it can be experienced on several levels rather than just ‘gotten.’” When people interpret art, they share certain socially common knowledge, but their varying experiences and differing familiarity with artistic elements introduce a more personal dimension to how they understand the meaning. This results in an infinite level of interaction among individuals when interpreting art.

ALL WRITING
↗