Museums and the Construction of Viewing

A reading response on museum narratives, absence, curatorial power, and audience participation.

Morandi Siyuan Wu

ART 380

2025

Although museums are generally viewed as neutral spaces for the preservation of culture and the transmission of knowledge, as Fred Wilson and Ivan Karp reveal in the article, the way in which the space is organized, the content of the displays chosen, how the narratives are decided, the identities and perspectives, and even the hint of lighting and routing, can all subtly lead the viewer to accept particular values and historical perspectives. This “natural” and “everyday” spatial structure is actually consolidating the hierarchy of society, the homogenization of historical narratives, and the invisible logic of who is the center of civilization and who is the “other”.

Leaving aside the museum itself, I have felt this idea deeply in the course of reading the article. This feeling comes from the layout of the article itself, which has a lot of text that has been bolded and nested in the body, and paragraphs that have been arranged in different shapes with interesting visual rhythms. And it made my reading process less of a linear acquisition of knowledge and more of a viewing experience curated by “typography”. As a reader, I had to change my reading habits and follow the text design. These designed reading paths are like the viewer's perspective in an exhibition space; they are not as neutral as one might think, reminding us that viewing and reading are both essentially orchestrated experiences.

Karp says in his essay, “people are aware more than they have personally experienced” (Wilson, 8). Much of our knowledge and perception of the world comes from indirect experience, especially in an age constructed by exhibitions, images, and social media. Most of what we “know” about history is often not because we have “experienced” it, but rather because we are constantly learning a version of it that museums and other institutions have “handed to us” in labels, spatial sequences, and visual images (of course we get a lot from educational institutions and resources, but these institutions are also deeply influenced by “authoritative” museum studies). Thus the museum has gone from being a “space for knowledge display” to a “consensus-making machine”. The article's reference to the museum's very limited information signage resonated with me. Often I am confronted with an exhibit and all I see is an extremely simplified title, with the occasional brief description or two. But my own information background, and that of most of the visitors I sense, is extremely limited, and our entire knowledge of the exhibit is often limited to that and a little extra. The curators thus hold a great deal of discourse power and become the sole constructor of this “experience”. Their stance, use of language, and choice of images will greatly influence the path of understanding of the audience. This curatorial mechanism is essentially a concentration of knowledge production power, and Wilson's statement “What they don't put on view says even more” is the core of his critique of this mechanism (Wilson, 5). The “absence” in an exhibition is often more revealing than the “presence”. In his “Mining the Museum,” he juxtaposes slave shackles with silverware and names the empty statue base “Harriet Tubman/Frederick Douglass,” powerfully revealing the museum's obscuring of black history. And this exposes the selective narratives of cultural institutions. This mechanism of “speaking through absence” reminds me of the photographs of survivors displayed on the walls of the Nanjing Massacre Memorial Museum: regardless of identity, merit, or gender, each individual is memorialized equally. This narrative strategy resists the “big man's view of history” and builds a way of remembering that focuses on the perspective of ordinary people.

At the same time, I also realized that when an artist becomes a curator like Wilson, or uses curating as a medium for art, the identity of the “artist as a structural interventionist” actually blurs the boundaries of the role. While criticizing the traditional power, he also constructs a new discourse mechanism. This also makes me wonder: is curating a neutral organization or a secondary creation? Is it possible for artists to fall into a new kind of “viewing manipulation” when they intervene in curating?

Then, is “exhibition” empowerment or solidification?

When marginalized groups, traumatic memories, and colonial history are exhibited, are we giving them the right to speak out? Or do we merely “aestheticize” them, turning them into an “othered image” for consumption? There has been a lot of discussion on Chinese social media about the British Museum's display of looted Chinese artifacts. Have the bronzes, masks, and murals that have been placed in white box spaces had their cultural context erased and become stand-ins for aesthetic spectacle? Has exhibiting them become a repackaging of violence? I think Wilson's exhibition structure is the beginning of a good answer to our questions. The exhibition should not only let the audience “see”, but also let them “take time to see”. Its Mining the Museum occupies three floors, and each part of the narrative requires walking, stopping, comparing and rereading. In this “non-quick-consumption” structure, the audience is not just browsing through the exhibition, but is forced to reorganize their own viewing rhythm and experience the density of history. This “viewing fatigue” is in fact a kind of anti-control mechanism - it in turn deconstructs the consumption and visual pleasure of modern exhibitions. The audience is forced to interact with the space and think.

This is not to say that it is wrong for the audience to “experience” history and understand culture through the curator's screening in an exhibition, but we must be aware of the bias it may constitute. As viewers, we need to think: what kind of attitude should we adopt to look at the contexts and choices in the exhibition? Can we have a more open, multi-contextual viewing structure? Is it possible for us, as viewers, to transform ourselves from being recipients of the design of the view into active questioners and co-constructors? The real question may not be “what is shown”, but “who decides what to show and what to hide”. When we realize that viewing itself is power, we can find another possibility between exhibition, curation, and historical narration: not a world to be exhibited, but a space to co-construct experience.

Question:

-Is curating a neutral organization or a secondary creation? Is it possible for artists to fall into a new kind of “viewing manipulation” when they intervene in curating?

-In traditional exhibitions, curators have the privilege of filtering and organizing narratives, while viewers are often only passive recipients of information. If we realize that an exhibition is essentially an arranged viewing mechanism, is it possible for the viewer to break the fixation of roles and become an active participant in the construction of meaning in such a structure?

Work Cited

Ober, Cara. “How Mining the Museum Changed the Art World.” BmoreArt, 20 Nov. 2023, bmoreart.com/2017/05/how-mining-the-museum-changed-the-art-world.html.

Wilson, Ivan KarpFred. “CONSTRUCTING THE SPECTACLE OF CULTURE IN MUSEUMS.” Taylor& Francis Group, Routledge, 1996, pp. 1–10.

ALL WRITING
↗